Publishing Scams on the High Seas: The Dream That Isn’t Real
For nonfiction authors sailing the often stormy waters of publishing, the journey can feel exciting—especially when a literary agent, publisher, or film producer comes calling. But beware: not every opportunity is what it seems. In this post, we’ll explore how to identify fake publishers, avoid author exploitation, and steer clear of scams that could cost you your rights, money, and peace of mind.
Fake Publishers and Flashy Websites: What to Watch For
One of my authors was eager to publish her second book and found a publisher with a gorgeous, professional-looking website. It featured glowing testimonials and claimed to have produced several bestsellers. But a simple look at the front matter of those books revealed the truth: none were published by that company.
Lesson: Do your homework. A sleek website isn’t proof of legitimacy. Publishing scammers often piggyback on the success of others to build false credibility.
Avoid Author Exploitation with Proper Verification
Another client purchased a “publishing package” from a company calling itself something patriotic—think “American Publishing US.” Despite the name, they weren’t based in the U.S., and their editors struggled with basic grammar. After paying thousands, the author had to redo much of the editing and formatting herself.
Lesson: Patriotic branding doesn’t guarantee quality or location. Always verify the company’s headquarters, team credentials, and work samples.
Hollywood Hoaxes: How to Identify Fake Publishers Pitching Fame
An excited gentleman once shared how a Hollywood-connected literary agent pursued him, offering a movie deal for his book. Unfortunately, it was all smoke and mirrors. Real producers don’t cold-call authors, and legitimate agents never ask for upfront fees.
Lesson: Genuine opportunities don’t come from unsolicited emails demanding money. If it feels like ego-stroking bait—it probably is.
ISBN Ownership: A Common Trap in the High Seas of Publishing
One of the most dangerous traps for authors is losing ownership of their book’s ISBN. A client of mine paid a publisher a hefty sum, only to discover they didn’t own the ISBN or the publishing rights. That publisher later disappeared—no support, no marketing, and no way for the author to regain control without a long and expensive battle.
Lesson: If you’re paying to publish, you should own your ISBN. In traditional publishing, the publisher fronts the cost and owns the ISBN. In hybrid or self-publishing, you need to ensure you retain your rights.
Understanding Vanity vs. Traditional Deals: Avoiding Author Exploitation
In a traditional deal, the publisher invests in editing, formatting, cover design, marketing, and distribution. You, the author, receive royalties and retain your copyright, while the publisher owns the book (via ISBN) and makes money from sales.
However, if a company asks for thousands of dollars and wants control of your ISBN, you’re likely dealing with a vanity publisher—often one that overpromises and underdelivers.
Lesson: Clarity in publishing contracts is essential. Understand who owns what before you commit.
Stay Safe: Final Advice for Navigating the High Seas of Publishing
Scammy publishers are more common than you think. Here’s how to stay safe:
- Agents should never charge you.
- Real publishers don’t pitch authors with unsolicited offers.
- Verify every claim a publisher makes.
- Don’t be fooled by flashy names or branding.
- Control your ISBN and retain your rights.
If you’re ever in doubt, consult resources like Writer Beware or reach out for advice. Sometimes a 5-minute conversation can save you months of frustration, thousands of dollars, and possibly even your manuscript.
Navigating With Confidence: Avoiding Scams and Finding Support
The publishing world can be overwhelming, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. Check the links in the description below for helpful tools and resources to guide your journey. And if you’ve received a suspicious offer, don’t hesitate to ask for a second opinion.
Remember: on the High Seas of Publishing, knowledge is your compass and skepticism is your anchor. Sail smart!
How Implementing These Ideas Helps Nonfiction Authors:
Applying the insights from this transcript equips nonfiction authors to avoid costly mistakes, retain control over their work, and make informed publishing decisions. Whether you’re self-publishing or considering a hybrid model, these lessons help you:
- Protect your intellectual property and royalties by ensuring you own your ISBN.
- Spot predatory publishers before you invest money you can’t get back.
- Build confidence navigating the publishing world with clarity and discernment.
These actions can dramatically reduce risk, save thousands of dollars, and prevent emotional burnout from exploitation.
3 Quick Actions to Help You Navigate The High Seas Of Publishing
- Look Up the Publisher on Writer Beware
Visit Writer Beware and search the name of any publisher or agent who has contacted you. If they’re on the watchlist—or suspiciously absent—proceed with caution.
- Check Book Credits in Amazon Previews
Go to Amazon, look up a book the publisher claims to have worked on, and use the “Look Inside” feature to inspect the copyright page. Does their name appear? If not, it’s a red flag.
- Confirm Who Owns the ISBN
Check your current or prospective publisher’s terms or ask directly: “Will I own the ISBN?” If they hesitate or dodge the question, that’s a sign to reconsider.
Keep writing and keep thriving,
Melody Ann
More Ideas To Excel Your Author Career
Are Book Awards Worth It | Do Book Awards Actually Matter
Do Book Awards Actually Matter for Nonfiction Authors? As a nonfiction author, you’ve likely seen books flaunting those shiny gold award seals. Maybe you’ve
High Seas of Publishing | Avoid Author Exploitation
Publishing Scams on the High Seas: The Dream That Isn’t Real For nonfiction authors sailing the often stormy waters of publishing, the journey can feel
Avoid the Author Trap | Too Good To Be True Publishing Deals
You’ve written your manuscript. You’re excited, hopeful, maybe even contacted by a publisher. But before you sign anything, you must know how to avoid